The Limits of International Pressure and Engaging the Chinese People
Human rights activist are upset over these remarks Sec. Clinton
WASHINGTON (AFP) – Amnesty International and a pro-Tibet group voiced shock Friday after US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton vowed not to let human rights concerns hinder cooperation with China.
Paying her first visit to Asia as the top US diplomat, Clinton said the United States would continue to press China on long-standing US concerns over human rights such as its rule over Tibet.
“But our pressing on those issues can’t interfere on the global economic crisis, the global climate change crisis and the security crisis,” Clinton told reporters in Seoul just before leaving for Beijing.
T. Kumar of Amnesty International USA said the global rights lobby was “shocked and extremely disappointed” by Clinton’s remarks.
“The United States is one of the only countries that can meaningfully stand up to China on human rights issues,” he said.
“But by commenting that human rights will not interfere with other priorities, Secretary Clinton damages future US initiatives to protect those rights in China,” he said.
Guess where North Korean refugees is ranked among the human rights causes in China?
The Olympics showed that incentives do encourage China to respect human rights. So what options do other countries have? A trade war is not an option, given the economic climate. “Pressure”, whatever the hell that is, doesn’t work.
What I never see is human rights groups making their case to the Chinese people themselves. One pattern I see is to paint all Chinese as enablers of human rights violations. I don’t think that accusation is false, but it’s not a way to make yourselves heard in the country.
I consider North Korean Human Rights to be a non-divisive issue (at least outside of South Korea). I believe LiNK and other groups could start making their case among overseas Chinese, many of whom have ties to China, in places like Taiwan and Hong Kong where they can operate freely, and, lastly, the Chinese internet population.
Despite the lack of political freedoms, Chinese people do have means to force change within their government. Groups will have to convince them that respect for human rights is an inherently Chinese trait.
While that does not make you a favorite within the Chinese government, but you might have the ear of the Chinese people.
We are witnessing the limits of the international community, it’s time to look domestically.











